Have I Got A Girl For You…

Despite what the title of this post might suggest, I’m not actually trying to match anybody up with the girl of their dreams, although I do appreciate a good love match as much as the next person.  I’m thinking about book heroines today, primarily because I read someone else’s post about unlikable heroines, and it got me thinking:  what really makes for the best heroine in a story?

Personally, I like my heroines a little on the flawed side.  Not unlikable, just imperfect. You know, like most of us are in real life.  For me, that makes them more relatable, and I get more emotionally invested in what happens to them.  Flaws are tricky things, though.  Too wimpy, and they’re just annoying.  (I never cared for the heroines whose only flaw is something along the lines of “she’s too caring” or “she’s too generous;” give me a flaw with some meat on its bones!)  But on the other hand if flaws are too shocking, the author risks alienating the reader.

But a lead character has to have something to overcome if there’s going to be any kind of story, whether it involves an inner struggle or an outer struggle, and sometimes a really juicy flaw can lead to a more profound storyline in the end–just so long as there’s still something about the character that makes you want to root for her more than you want to throttle her.

Blake Snyder wrote a terrific book about that kind of thing called Save the Cat, and even though it’s aimed primarily at screenwriters, it’s a wonderful tool for novelists, too.  In it, he describes how it isn’t enough for a character to be “cool;” there’s got to be something about her that makes you care.  There has to be a moment early on in the story that somehow defines the character and makes us care about her and whether or not she achieves her goal, and that’s what he calls the “save the cat” scene.  It doesn’t literally have to involve saving a cat from a tree or a burning building, but I’m sure you get the general idea.

So what do you look for in a heroine?

2 thoughts on “Have I Got A Girl For You…

  1. Flaws are good. It makes you feel like they are on your level and not some make believe perfect in every way, annoying little thing. Ha! I actually like witty, kind of spry, light hearted heroines. Ones that think or say things that make you laugh or think, “I can not believe she just said that!” But in truth you were thinking it too. You know to side step this a little, I watched a Movie with my nephew during the holidays and he really liked it. He said, “I really liked that movie. A good movie is supposed to make you feel for the main character and want her to succeed.” Smart boy for a 15 year old watching a cartoon. Relatable, fun, a bit feisty, but with a good all round heart…..yup, that would be my idea of a heroine. Have fun with it Christine 🙂

    • Ha! That IS a smart 15-year-old! 🙂 I know what you mean about liking characters that will say things we’re all really thinking; you can kind of live vicariously through them–and all without leaving the comfort of your living room. Heh heh…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *